Ryan Shepard
About Author
February 10, 2025
 in 
Recipes

Homemade Strawberry Pop-Tarts – Flaky, Buttery & Filled with Love

Valentine’s Day looks a little different when you have tiny humans running the show. Gone are the days of candlelit dinners and overpriced prix-fixe menus; now, we’re knee-deep in construction paper hearts, half-eaten chocolates, and a toddler who just declared their undying love for a rock they found outside.

But you know what? I love this season of life. And I love any excuse to turn an ordinary day into a tiny bit of magic.

Enter: Homemade Strawberry Pop-Tarts. They’re flaky, buttery, and filled with real homemade strawberry jam—just like the ones we grew up eating, but better. These are real pop-tarts, made with love (and hopefully, not too much toddler spit).

They’re perfect for a Valentine’s morning breakfast, an after-school treat, or a fun baking project with your little sous chefs. And the best part? You don’t have to stick with boring rectangles—use cookie cutters to make heart-shaped, star-shaped, or even teddy bear-shaped Pop-Tarts! Because if we’re already embracing the chaos, we might as well make it cute.

And if they turn out lopsided? Just call them rustic and move on.

Why I Love This Recipe

  • It’s nostalgic – If you grew up eating Pop-Tarts straight out of the toaster (or let’s be real, straight out of the wrapper), this homemade version will take you back. But better.
  • It’s fun for kids – Toddlers + sprinkles = instant entertainment.
  • It’s customizable – Change the filling, change the icing, make fun shapes—whatever suits your mood!
  • It’s a multi-use recipe – Any leftover strawberry jam can double for PB&Js, yogurt topping, or (my favorite) drizzled over vanilla ice cream with olive oil and flaky salt. Trust me.

Why You Should Make This Recipe

Better than store-bought – Flaky, buttery pastry with real fruit filling? Say no more.
Customizable – Make heart-shaped ones for Valentine’s Day, pumpkin-shaped for fall, or use whatever fruit jam you love.
Make-ahead friendly – Freeze extras for an easy grab-and-go breakfast.
Simple ingredients – No weird preservatives or artificial stuff.

Pro Tips for Making the Best Pop-Tarts

Use cold butter – Just like making pie dough, cold butter = flakier pastry.
Don’t overfill – Too much jam will cause leaks. Stay strong.
Seal well – Use a fork to crimp the edges securely so they don’t burst open in the oven.
Let them cool before icing – I know, waiting is hard. But icing too soon = a melted mess.
Make extra jam – Because once you taste it, you’ll want to put it on everything.

Anticipated Questions

Q: Can I use store-bought jam instead?
A: Of course! But if you have 15 minutes, I highly recommend making it from scratch—it’s so much fresher and tastier.

Q: Can I make these gluten-free?
A: Yes! Swap the flour for a 1:1 gluten-free baking blend and add an extra tablespoon of water if needed.

Q: How do I store leftover Pop-Tarts?
A: Keep them in an airtight container at room temperature for 2 days, or refrigerate for up to 5 days.

Q: Can I freeze these?
A: Absolutely! Freeze un-iced Pop-Tarts in a single layer, then transfer to a freezer bag. Reheat in the toaster or oven.

Q: Can I use other fruit fillings?
A: Yes! Try raspberry, blueberry, or even Nutella for a chocolatey version.

Final Thoughts

These  Strawberry Pop-Tarts are flaky, jam-filled little pockets of joy, perfect for Valentine’s Day—or any day that calls for something special. And if they turn out a little wonky? Just call them rustic and enjoy every bite. Oh, and that extra jam? PB&Js are great, but don’t forget the vanilla ice cream, a drizzle of good olive oil, and a pinch of flaky salt. Just trust me. Happy baking, and Happy Valentine’s Day!

Leave a comment!

More Posts

You Might Also Like

Read More
Lifestyle

Don’t Have Time for a Fancy Valentine’s Day Meal? Here Are Store-Bought Options That Taste as Good as Homemade

No time to cook for Valentine’s Day? These easy store-bought meals—from pasta to sushi, soups, and desserts—taste homemade with zero stress. Plus, the best canned cocktails to pair with dinner!
Read More
Relationships

Black-Owned Hotels & B&Bs for a Romantic Valentine’s Getaway

Discover Black-owned hotels & B&Bs perfect for a romantic getaway! From luxury resorts to cozy inns, nurture your relationship while supporting Black hospitality.
Read More
Recipes

Smoked Trout Tartine with Herby Cream Cheese Spread

Elevate breakfast with this Smoked Trout Tartine featuring herbed cream cheese, pickled red onions, and capers. It's elegant, easy, and perfect for any brunch!

Latest Posts

Stay up-to-date on the latest blog content
Back Home

Get in Touch

Let’s create something great together
@import url('https://fonts.googleapis.com/css2?family=Lato:wght@400&display=swap'); .fast-comments, textarea { font-family: 'Lato', sans-serif; }